Difference between revisions of "Rendering engines comparison"

From Blender for Architecture
Jump to: navigation, search
 
(27 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{WIP}}
 
 
 
Blender could be used with many external renderers.
 
Blender could be used with many external renderers.
 
[http://www.kino3d.com/mediawiki/index.php/Rendering_Engines List of Rendering engines]
 
  
 
The aim of this webpage is to show which rendrerers suit your needs with pro and cons.
 
The aim of this webpage is to show which rendrerers suit your needs with pro and cons.
Line 10: Line 6:
 
{| cellspacing="2" style="border: 1px solid; font-size: 90%; text-align: left; background-color: #eeeeee"
 
{| cellspacing="2" style="border: 1px solid; font-size: 90%; text-align: left; background-color: #eeeeee"
 
! NAME__________
 
! NAME__________
! HOMEPAGE__________________________________________
+
! HOMEPAGE____________________________________
 
! RAYTRACING__
 
! RAYTRACING__
! G.I._______
+
! G.I.________
! QMC_____
+
 
! OPENSOURCE__
 
! OPENSOURCE__
! EXPORTER_____
+
! EXPORTER__________
! PLATEFORM
+
! PLATEFORM________________________
 
|-
 
|-
|[[Rendering engines comparison#Blender Internal|Blender Internal]]
+
|[[#Blender Internal|Blender Internal]]
 
|http://blender.org
 
|http://blender.org
 
|yes
 
|yes
|sort of
 
 
|no
 
|no
 
|yes
 
|yes
|:-)
+
|integrated
 +
|Windows, Linux, OSX, Solaris, FreeBSD, Irix
 
|-
 
|-
|[[Rendering engines comparison#Yafray|Yafray]]
+
|[[#Yafray|Yafray]]
 
|http://yafray.org
 
|http://yafray.org
|yes
 
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|integrated
 
|integrated
 +
|Windows, Linux, OSX
 
|-
 
|-
|[[Rendering engines comparison#Povray|Povray]]
+
|[[#Povray|Povray]]
 
|http://povray.org
 
|http://povray.org
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
|?
 
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|Blender mod or script
 
|Blender mod or script
 +
|Windows, Linux, OSX
 
|-
 
|-
 
|[[Sunflow]]
 
|[[Sunflow]]
 
|http://sunflow.sourceforge.net/
 
|http://sunflow.sourceforge.net/
|yes
 
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
Line 50: Line 44:
 
|Script
 
|Script
 
|Java
 
|Java
 +
|-
 +
|[[Luxrender]]
 +
|http://luxrender2.org/
 +
|yes
 +
|yes
 +
|yes
 +
|Script
 +
|Windows, Linux, OSX
 
|-
 
|-
 
|[[Winosi]]
 
|[[Winosi]]
 
|http://www.winosi.onlinehome.de/
 
|http://www.winosi.onlinehome.de/
 
|yes
 
|yes
|yes
 
|?
 
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 +
|Script
 +
|Windows, Linux
 
|-
 
|-
|[[Aqsis]]
+
|[[#Aqsis|Aqsis]]
 
|http://www.aqsis.org/xoops/modules/news/
 
|http://www.aqsis.org/xoops/modules/news/
 
|yes
 
|yes
|?
 
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 +
|Script
 +
|Windows, Linux, OSX
 
|-
 
|-
|[[Kerkythea]]
+
|[[#Kerkythea|Kerkythea]]
|http://www.softlab.ntua.gr/~jpanta/Graphics/Kerkythea/
+
|http://www.kerkythea.net/joomla/
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
|?
 
 
|no
 
|no
|yes
+
|Blender mod or script
 +
|Windows, Linux
 
|-
 
|-
|[[Rendering engines comparison#Indigo|Indigo]]
+
|[[#Indigo|Indigo]]
 
|http://www.indigorenderer.com/
 
|http://www.indigorenderer.com/
 
|yes
 
|yes
 +
|yes
 +
|no, but it's for free as well
 +
|Script
 +
|Windows, Linux, OSX
 +
|-
 +
|[[PRman]]
 +
|http://renderman.pixar.com/
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|yes
 
|no
 
|no
 +
|?
 +
|Windows, OSX
 +
|-
 +
|[[#Mental Ray|Mental Ray]]
 +
|http://www.autodesk.com/mentalray
 
|yes
 
|yes
 +
|yes
 +
|no
 +
|Blender mod
 +
|Windows, Linux, OSX
 +
|-
 +
|[[#V-Ray|V-Ray]]
 +
|http://www.chaosgroup.com/en/2/index.html
 +
|yes
 +
|yes
 +
|no
 +
|Script, Full integration in development
 +
|Windows, Linux
 
|}
 
|}
  
Line 91: Line 118:
 
=== Cons ===
 
=== Cons ===
 
No GI (only Ambiant Occlusion). Slow antialiasing.
 
No GI (only Ambiant Occlusion). Slow antialiasing.
 +
 +
 +
== Yafray ==
 +
 +
=== Pro ===
 +
Full GI. Nice realistic rendering. Integrated
 +
 +
=== Cons ===
 +
Texture alpha channel is ignored for shadow casting... :-(
 +
 +
[[Talk:Rendering_engines_comparison#Transparent_shadows_with_Yafray|Transparent material casts solid dark shadow... :-(]]
 +
 +
Yafray ignores objects inserted as group.
  
 
== Povray ==
 
== Povray ==
Line 96: Line 136:
  
 
=== Pro ===
 
=== Pro ===
 +
Full GI.
 +
Nice realistic rendering.
 
Fast
 
Fast
  
 
=== Cons ===
 
=== Cons ===
(Mod) Doesn't use the Blender orco mapping
+
Doesn't use yet all functions of Blender like Orco mapping, background picture, skies...
  
== Yafray ==
+
== Indigo ==
  
 
=== Pro ===
 
=== Pro ===
full GI. Nice realistic rendering. Integrated
+
Full GI.  
 +
Very realistic and fast renderings.
  
 
=== Cons ===
 
=== Cons ===
Transparent material casts solid dark shadow... :-(
+
Closed source
  
 +
== Kerkythea ==
 +
Blender mod and script http://cobalt3d.free.fr/images_3dblender/kerkythea/documentation/Blender2Kerkythea_en.htm
  
== Indigo ==
+
=== Pro ===
 +
Full GI.
 +
Accurate lighting.
 +
Fast.
 +
Lot of tweaks.
 +
 
 +
=== Cons ===
 +
Closed source.
 +
Only available on Windows and Linux x86.
 +
 
 +
== Mental Ray ==
 +
Blender mod http://blenderartists.org/forum/showthread.php?t=74765
 +
 
 +
== V-Ray ==
 +
Script: http://blender.bevice.ru/
  
 
=== Pro ===
 
=== Pro ===
full GI. Nice realistic rendering. Integrated
+
Very Fast and very good for comercial use.
  
 
=== Cons ===
 
=== Cons ===
Very slow
+
None ?
Non open source
+

Latest revision as of 09:49, 30 March 2009

Blender could be used with many external renderers.

The aim of this webpage is to show which rendrerers suit your needs with pro and cons.


NAME__________ HOMEPAGE____________________________________ RAYTRACING__ G.I.________ OPENSOURCE__ EXPORTER__________ PLATEFORM________________________
Blender Internal http://blender.org yes no yes integrated Windows, Linux, OSX, Solaris, FreeBSD, Irix
Yafray http://yafray.org yes yes yes integrated Windows, Linux, OSX
Povray http://povray.org yes yes yes Blender mod or script Windows, Linux, OSX
Sunflow http://sunflow.sourceforge.net/ yes yes yes Script Java
Luxrender http://luxrender2.org/ yes yes yes Script Windows, Linux, OSX
Winosi http://www.winosi.onlinehome.de/ yes yes yes Script Windows, Linux
Aqsis http://www.aqsis.org/xoops/modules/news/ yes yes yes Script Windows, Linux, OSX
Kerkythea http://www.kerkythea.net/joomla/ yes yes no Blender mod or script Windows, Linux
Indigo http://www.indigorenderer.com/ yes yes no, but it's for free as well Script Windows, Linux, OSX
PRman http://renderman.pixar.com/ yes yes no ? Windows, OSX
Mental Ray http://www.autodesk.com/mentalray yes yes no Blender mod Windows, Linux, OSX
V-Ray http://www.chaosgroup.com/en/2/index.html yes yes no Script, Full integration in development Windows, Linux


Blender Internal

Pro

Fully integrated. All the power of Blender material panel

Cons

No GI (only Ambiant Occlusion). Slow antialiasing.


Yafray

Pro

Full GI. Nice realistic rendering. Integrated

Cons

Texture alpha channel is ignored for shadow casting... :-(

Transparent material casts solid dark shadow... :-(

Yafray ignores objects inserted as group.

Povray

You could use either the Povanim script or the custom Blender build with Povray mod.

Pro

Full GI. Nice realistic rendering. Fast

Cons

Doesn't use yet all functions of Blender like Orco mapping, background picture, skies...

Indigo

Pro

Full GI. Very realistic and fast renderings.

Cons

Closed source

Kerkythea

Blender mod and script http://cobalt3d.free.fr/images_3dblender/kerkythea/documentation/Blender2Kerkythea_en.htm

Pro

Full GI. Accurate lighting. Fast. Lot of tweaks.

Cons

Closed source. Only available on Windows and Linux x86.

Mental Ray

Blender mod http://blenderartists.org/forum/showthread.php?t=74765

V-Ray

Script: http://blender.bevice.ru/

Pro

Very Fast and very good for comercial use.

Cons

None ?